reaching everyone for active citizenry @ home
Singapore Government
 
 
Welcome to the REACH Portal.

i-REACH (May 2013) is out now.
 
Find us on
Twitter Facebook SMS YouTube RSS

Your Feedback Our Response - Archives

17 Nov 2011, 11.14AM
2 comments & replies |by REACH Administrator | Replies to Feedback
The first sitting of the 12th Parliament last month certainly attracted much public attention, with many Singaporeans intently following the various Parliamentary speeches on TV, online, as well as in the newspapers. Amidst this, some wondered why the proceedings were not telecast in their entirety on TV or published in full in the papers. REACH also received feedback on this, with some enquiring whether video clips of the MPs’ speeches can be made available online.

Similar sentiments were expressed on the Straits Times Forum. Here, we bring you the replies from the Clerk of Parliament and MediaCorp to one such letter sent to the Straits Times Forum, to close the loop with contributors.
Reply from Clerk of Parliament

We thank Mr Lee Seck Kay for his suggestion ('Parliamentary proceedings should be broadcast in full' on 9 Nov 2011). The public is free to attend Parliament sittings, for which Parliament has made provision for some 240 seats in the public gallery.

Live telecasts are provided for significant parliamentary business such as the annual Budget statement, the President's Address at the opening of Parliament and important ministerial statements.

For its TV and online coverage use, MediaCorp has the full video footage of each sitting and the extent of news coverage is a media decision.

Videos of entire speeches made by Members of Parliament can now be viewed online at MediaCorp's Channel NewsAsia website (channelnewsasia.com).

For verbatim records of these speeches, the Singapore Parliament Reports are published on our website (parliament.gov.sg) and LawNet (lawnet.com.sg) within a week after the end of proceedings.

We regularly review the feasibility of other avenues to raise public awareness of parliamentary proceedings and will take Mr Lee's feedback into consideration.

Ng Sheau Jiuan (Ms)
Clerk of Parliament
----------------------------------------
Reply from Mediacorp

We thank Mr Lee Seck Kay for his letter on 9 Nov 2011 ('Parliamentary proceedings should be broadcast in full').

Video clips of all the speeches made at last month's first sitting of the new Parliament have been uploaded and can be viewed online at url: channelnewsasia.com/parliament.

Each time Parliament sits, the news reports of the debates aim to inform our viewers of the key points that make the news for the day.

Separately, we produce the In Parliament programmes, which provide longer versions of the thrust of discussions in the House. These serve different quarters of viewers who want only the day's highlights.

For others like Mr Lee, who may prefer to view the speeches in their entirety and at times that are convenient for them, they can log in to watch the video clips on channelnewsasia.com after they have been uploaded.

Han Chuan Quee (Ms)
Vice-President, Corporate Services
Channel NewsAsia
MediaCorp
3138 views  |  2 comments & replies  | 
Guest
1 Dec 2011, 9.02PM
To both the Singapore Parliament and Mediacorp,

Although verbatim records of speeches are published on the parliament's website, video archives of unedited speeches are far more accessible and transparent for the public to observe the parliament proceedings.

What is available currently on channelnewsasia.com are a handful of selected, edited video clips of the latest parliament sessions, rather than a well-archived library of videos clips of past parliament sessions. I understand the need to provide summary clips of parliament proceedings for news segments and parliament television programmes, but this should not be an excuse or reason against making unedited parliament proceedings available to the public, as it will serve both the transparency and accountability duty of the parliament to the people.

Moreover, to allow a commercial media company - Mediacorp, to have full video records and publish only selected, edited parliamentary videos, negates the transparency of parliament as these videos are mostly edited and used to report a certain news angle, which as objective as they may be, poses the risk of bias news reporting.

The Singapore Parliament should follow the example of other parliaments around the world, such as the UK Parliament, in providing both live streaming and archiving unedited footage of parliament proceedings to the public to improve the parliament's transparency and accountability to the public. The video capturing, streaming, archiving and hosting should be done by the parliament itself instead of assigning it to a third-party commercial news agency, so that the public can access unedited parliament proceedings through the parliament's own website.


Sincerely,
More Transparency Please
Guest
1 Dec 2011, 9.38PM
An informed citizenry and electorate requires access to important information of policymaking proceedings in the parliament.

If the Government is truly concerned with engaging its citizens, then it should begin at this fundamental level of providing access to unedited parliament sessions footage.

As Ms Ng, the clerk of parliament puts it - there are only 240 seats in the public gallery. What then should be the difference of providing the 240 members of the public an unedited parliament session compared to all the others who couldn't get a seat?

There simply isn't any reason for the Singapore Parliament not to provide video footage and archival in its own capacity and having the need to leave it to a commercial news agency to carry out its duty. Cost cannot be an issue here looking at how well maintained the Parliament building is.

Let us see how the government is truly sincere in engaging its citizens by providing us access to parliament proceedings. We are certainly able to comprehend some policymaking jargon and do not need any news outlet to summarise or simplify talking points for us.


Freedom of Information, though not in our Constitution (unbelievable), is what we need.
Your Feedback Our Response - Archives


Search Archives

Best viewed at 1024*768 resolution with IE 7.0 or FireFox 3.0